Fin Maverick
QuarksCourses
PartnershipsShowdown
Log inSign up
Interview tracksAll
1Investment Banking
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
2Equity Research
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
3Venture Capital
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
4Private Equity
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
5Hedge Funds
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
6Quant
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
7Financial Analysis
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
8Private Wealth Management
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
9Debt Capital Markets
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
10Risk Management
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
11Derivatives Foundation
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
12Portfolio Management
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
13Mutual Fund Mastery
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
032

Case 032Sector economicsHard

Ambrosa Developers pre-sold Rs 5,000 crore of flats this year but books revenue on completion, so reported revenue is Rs 2,200 crore. Value it on net asset value instead of P/E.

1The situation

Ambrosa Developers builds residential towers. It sells flats while they are under construction, collecting instalments as work progresses, but books revenue only when a project is completed and handed over, two to three years after the sale. Pre-sales over the last five years were Rs 1,900, 2,100, 2,300, 3,400 and 5,000 crore. Reported revenue this year is Rs 2,200 crore at a 14% net margin, Rs 308 crore of profit on 25 crore shares, and the shares trade at Rs 240.

From the project disclosures: on flats sold but not yet booked, customers still owe Rs 5,000 crore and Ambrosa still has Rs 3,200 crore to spend building them. Unsold flats in ongoing projects are worth Rs 6,000 crore at current prices with Rs 2,400 crore still to spend. The land bank, already paid for, can support Rs 20,000 crore of sales at a building cost of Rs 13,000 crore, launched over about five years. Net debt, after the customer advances already collected, is Rs 900 crore. Tax is 25% of profit and the discount rate is 12%.

2Your task

Why does P/E mislead here, and what does a net asset value give per share?

Quick check

Ambrosa trades at about 19.5x this year's earnings. What happens to that P/E on year 7's earnings if nothing more is sold?

Worked solution

Try it on paper, then open one step at a time.

30-second answerThe answer to give first

On net asset value Ambrosa is worth about Rs 5,597 crore, Rs 224 a share, so at Rs 240 it trades near 1.07x NAV. P/E misleads because booked revenue reflects flats sold two to three years ago: the same price is 19.5x this year's earnings and about 10x year 7's. NAV discounts the cash still to come from sold flats, unsold flats and the land bank, then subtracts net debt.

Step 1Why does a developer's P/E tell you so little?

A tailor who takes orders in January and delivers suits in March books nothing in January, however busy the shop is. A developer is the same tailor with a two to three year gap. Pre-sales measure the business being done today; booked revenue measures the business done two or three years ago, so any multiple of booked earnings is a multiple of old news. When pre-sales jump, as Ambrosa's did from Rs 2,300 crore to Rs 5,000 crore in two years, the P/E looks expensive now and cheap later with no change in the company.

Pre-sales lead, booked revenue follows two to three years later, Rs crore1,900Year 12,100Year 22,3001,800Year 33,4002,000Year 45,0002,200Year 52,850Year 64,200Year 7TodayPre-sales: flats sold that yearRevenue booked on completionAlready locked in
Ambrosa's pre-sales rose from Rs 1,900 crore to Rs 5,000 crore over five years, while booked revenue follows two to three years behind at Rs 2,200 crore this year, with Rs 2,850 crore and Rs 4,200 crore already locked in for the next two years.
Step 2How do you build the net asset value?

Split the business into buckets of future cash, value each, and subtract what is owed. For every bucket the cash to count is money still to come in, less money still to spend, less tax on the profit, discounted for how long it takes. Customer advances already collected are in the cash balance, which is why net debt is taken after them and why only the Rs 5,000 crore still owed counts for sold flats. Tax is on accounting profit: a 28% margin on the Rs 9,550 crore of sold flats not yet booked, 32% on unsold flats, and Rs 5,500 crore on the land bank after its book cost. This is net asset valueFor a developer, the present value of the cash its projects and land will produce, less its net debt; it values the business as a pipeline rather than as a stream of reported profits. in its simplest form.

Bucket, Rs croreStill to collectStill to spendTaxCashYearsPV at 12%
Sold flats not yet booked5,0003,2006691,1321.5955
Unsold flats in ongoing projects6,0002,4004803,1202.52,350
Land bank, already paid for20,00013,0001,3755,6255.03,192
Net debt after advances(900)
Net asset value5,597
Per share, 25 crore sharesRs 224
Ambrosa's three buckets are worth Rs 6,497 crore today; less Rs 900 crore of net debt the net asset value is Rs 5,597 crore, Rs 224 a share against a price of Rs 240.
Net asset value, Rs crore: present value of each bucket less net debt955Sold, not booked+2,350Unsold flats+3,192Land bank-900Net debt5,597NAVMarket value Rs 6,000 croreRs 224 a shareP/NAV 1.07x
Sold flats, unsold flats and the land bank are worth Rs 955, 2,350 and 3,192 crore; after Rs 900 crore of net debt Ambrosa's NAV is Rs 5,597 crore, a little below its Rs 6,000 crore market value.
Step 3What is the judgement, and what moves it?

At Rs 240 the market pays about 1.07x NAV, a small premium that amounts to paying for land Ambrosa has not bought yet. The land bank is the largest and least certain bucket: it is five years away and its value depends on prices and building costs no one knows today. A 10% fall in the land bank's sale value removes Rs 2,000 crore of inflow, about Rs 34 a share after tax and discounting. Close with that sensitivity and with the pre-sales trend, the leading indicator the NAV quietly assumes will continue.

Where candidates lose it

The common loss is counting the full value of sold flats and also counting the advances already collected in cash, which values the same rupees twice. Net debt after advances and only the money still owed is the consistent pair.

The second is calling the stock expensive at nearly 20x earnings. Booked profit trails selling by years here, and the interviewer wants you to switch to the pipeline before you reach a view.

What the interviewer asks next

  • How would a 5% rise in construction costs change the land bank value?
  • Why might a developer with strong pre-sales still run short of cash?
  • When would you prefer price to book or EV/EBITDA for a property company?
← Case 031Build Nirvela Bank's return on equity from an ROA tree: margin, fees, cost to income, credit cost, tax and leverage. Where is the gap to a peer earning 17%?Case 033 →Over five years Mardanta Infra reported cumulative profit of Rs 2,000 crore but operating cash flow of only Rs 600 crore, with unbilled revenue rising every year. What is happening, and what would you ask management?

Company names and figures are illustrative.

Fin Maverick

Finance education that ends in a job, not a certificate that gathers dust. Built for young India.

LEARN
CalculatorsFrameworksComparisonsInterview RoadmapsShowdown
RESOURCES
All CoursesFree CoursesBootcampsNISMQuarksAI for Finance
COMPANY
AboutJob openingPartnership
LEGAL
Privacy PolicyTerms & ConditionsContent LicenseReturn & Refund Policy
© 2026 FIN MAVERICK / BUILT FOR INDIA.DO FINANCE, DO NOT JUST READ ABOUT IT.