Case 098Stock pitchCore
Write a one-page investment memo on a PVC pipe maker trading at 32x earnings, with revenue of Rs 3,100 crore, 30,000 dealers and resin prices that swing 25% a year. What goes in each section?
1The situation
Grevanto Pipes makes PVC pipes and fittings for plumbing and farm irrigation. Revenue is Rs 3,100 crore at a 13% EBITDA margin; after depreciation of Rs 60 crore, interest of Rs 10 crore and 25% tax, profit is about Rs 250 crore, EPS Rs 10 on 25 crore shares. The stock is Rs 320, 32x earnings, a market value of Rs 7,992 crore.
Grevanto sells through 30,000 dealers and plumbers ask for it by name. PVC resin is about 55% of revenue and its price swings about 25% a year; Grevanto holds 45 days of resin and passes price changes on within weeks. Management targets 15% volume growth. Your cost of equity is 12%, and you expect the multiple to settle near 25x in five years.
2Your task
Write the memo: the view, the thesis, the valuation and the risks, with what you would monitor.
Quick check
At 32x, what EPS growth for five years does Grevanto need to earn a 12% return, exiting at 25x?
Worked solution
Try it on paper, then open one step at a time.
30-second answerThe answer to give first
The memo's view: a quality franchise priced for about 18% EPS growth, so hold off at 32x and look again on a resin-led dip. The thesis is the 30,000-dealer network, which lets Grevanto grow volumes near 15%. The valuation shows 15% EPS growth earns only 9.5% a year from here, below a 12% cost of equity. Each risk gets a trigger: a resin fall of 15% or more in a quarter, stalling dealer additions, or a rival adding capacity.
Step 1What goes first on the page?
The view, in one line, before any history. A reader who stops after the first sentence should know what you think and why. A memo leads with the view and gives each risk a trigger to watch; everything between exists to support those two. Grevanto's line: a quality franchise priced for about 18% EPS growth, so the price, not the business, is the issue. Minto's pyramid principle, answer first and support after, is the structure most fund managers expect.
Step 2What carries the thesis?
One number the reader can check next quarter. 30,000 dealers selling Rs 10.3 lakh of Grevanto pipe each a year is the moat: a plumber asks for the brand, the dealer stocks it, and a new entrant has to win both. Growth comes from adding dealers in smaller towns and from housing and irrigation demand. Resin is a cost that swings, not a thesis; Grevanto passes it on within weeks, so it moves quarterly margins, not the long-run story. Think of a milk cooperative whose collection network is the asset, whatever the price of fodder does in any one season.
Step 3What does the valuation section need to say?
What the price assumes, not just the multiple. At Rs 320, a 12% annual return with an exit at 25x needs EPS of Rs 22.5 in five years. That is 17.7% EPS growth a year; at management's 15%, the return is 9.5% a year, short of a 12% cost of equity. So the stock is fairly to fully priced: a buyer at 32x is paying today for growth above the company's own target. The de-ratingA fall in the multiple investors pay for each rupee of earnings, independent of any change in the earnings themselves. from 32x to 25x is doing the damage; if the multiple held at 32x, 15% growth would return 15% a year.
Step 4How do you write the risks so they are useful?
Give each one a trigger you could see in a monthly or quarterly update. Resin: a fall of 25% would force a write-down of about Rs 53 crore on 45 days of stock, 13% of a year's EBITDA, so the trigger is a resin fall of 15% or more in a quarter. Distribution: dealer additions falling below the pace needed for 15% volume growth. Competition: a rival announcing capacity in Grevanto's core states. Close the memo with the monitor list: resin prices monthly, dealer count and volume growth quarterly, and working capital days, which show whether growth is being bought with dealer credit.
| Risk | Trigger | Size |
|---|---|---|
| Resin price fall | Resin down 15%+ in a quarter | About Rs 53 crore one-off at a 25% fall |
| Dealer growth stalls | Net dealer additions below plan two quarters running | Volume growth nearer 10% than 15% |
| New capacity | A rival announces a plant in a core state | Price pressure on fittings, the higher-margin half |
| Growth bought with credit | Receivable days up 10+ days | Cash conversion falls behind profit |
Where candidates lose it
The typical memo opens with two paragraphs of company history and buries the view on page two, or never states one. A reader who must hunt for the conclusion assumes there is none.
The second miss is listing risks with no trigger: resin volatility, competition, the economy. A risk without a trigger cannot be monitored, so it does no work in the memo.
What the interviewer asks next
- What would you need to see to move the view to positive at Rs 320?
- How would the memo change if you were writing it for a short seller?
- Which one chart would you add if you had half a page more?
Asked at Fidelity Investments, Equity Research Intern Interview, Toronto, 2026 (Wall Street Oasis): First round was submitting an investment memo. Second Round 1 on 1 with Director.
Company names and figures are illustrative.
