Fin Maverick
QuarksCourses
PartnershipsShowdown
Log inSign up
Interview tracksAll
1Investment Banking
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
2Equity Research
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
3Venture Capital
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
4Private Equity
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
5Hedge Funds
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
6Quant
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
7Financial Analysis
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
8Private Wealth Management
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
9Debt Capital Markets
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
10Risk Management
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
11Derivatives Foundation
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
12Portfolio Management
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
13Mutual Fund Mastery
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
100

Case 100DCF and intrinsic valueCore

A metals company's EBITDA over eight years was Rs 300, 450, 600, 250, 150, 400, 700 and 500 crore, and this year's is Rs 500 crore. Peers trade at 6x mid-cycle EBITDA. What EBITDA would you capitalise, what value does that give, and why not use this year's figure?

1The situation

Tamrav Metals, an invented aluminium smelter, has reported EBITDA over the last eight years of Rs 300, 450, 600, 250, 150, 400, 700 and 500 crore, in that order. The current year is tracking Rs 500 crore. Capacity has not changed in that time.

Listed peers trade at about 6x EBITDA, but equity analysts describe that as a multiple of mid-cycle EBITDA rather than of any particular year. A client considering a bid asks you what Tamrav is worth and whether this year's Rs 500 crore is the right base.

2Your task

Choose the EBITDA to capitalise and defend it, compute the value, show what using this year's figure or the trough would have done, and explain how the market's multiple already contains the cycle.

Quick check

What is the average of the eight years of EBITDA?

Worked solution

Try it on paper, then open one step at a time.

30-second answerThe answer to give first

Capitalise mid-cycle EBITDA of about Rs 419 crore, the eight-year average, which at 6x gives Rs 2,512 crore. This year's Rs 500 crore would give Rs 3,000 crore, 19% more, because 500 is a good year in a business that has earned anything from Rs 150 crore to Rs 700 crore on the same plant. The 6x is a multiple of the average; put it on a peak year and you have paid twice for the cycle.

Step 1Why is this year the wrong base?

Because this year is a point on a cycle, and the business is the whole cycle. Eight years on the same capacity produced between Rs 150 crore and Rs 700 crore of EBITDA, so no single year describes what the plant earns; the average, Rs 419 crore, comes closest. A farmer does not value his land on the harvest after a perfect monsoon, and a buyer does not pay for it on the drought year; both look at ten years of yields. Tamrav's Rs 500 crore is 19% above the average and the second-best figure in nine years. The variation is large, a coefficient of variation of about 41%, which is what cyclical means in numbers.

Eight years of EBITDA swing from 150 to 700; the line is what the market pays for200400600300Y-8450Y-7600Y-6250Y-5150Y-4400Y-3700Y-2500Y-1500Now419mid-cycleMid-cycle 419 x 6 = Rs 2,512 crore; this year's 500 x 6 = Rs 3,000 crore, 19% too much.Green: EBITDA above the average. Red dashed: the gap below it. The market prices the line, not the bar.
Tamrav's EBITDA swung from Rs 150 crore to Rs 700 crore over eight years around an average of Rs 419 crore; at 6x the average is worth Rs 2,512 crore, while this year's Rs 500 crore would give Rs 3,000 crore, 19% more for the same plant.
Step 2What does 6x mid-cycle actually mean?

The market applies a steady multiple to a steady number, so the multiple on any given year's EBITDA swings the other way: Rs 2,512 crore is 5.0x this year's 500, 3.6x the peak 700 and 16.8x the trough 150. That is why cyclical stocks look cheapest at the top of the cycle, when earnings are high and the multiple is low, and most expensive at the bottom. A buyer who sees 6x peers and 500 of EBITDA and pays Rs 3,000 crore has applied a mid-cycle multiple to a near-peak year, which counts the good part of the cycle twice: once in the multiple, which already assumes some good years, and once in the base.

Base EBITDA, Rs croreFigureValue at 6xAgainst mid-cycle
Trough year150900-64%
Last five years average4002,400-4%
Eight year average (mid-cycle)4192,5120%
Nine years including this year4282,567+2%
This year5003,000+19%
Peak year7004,200+67%
The choice of base moves Tamrav's value from Rs 900 crore on the trough to Rs 4,200 crore on the peak, and the averages cluster near Rs 2,512 crore, which is why the base matters more than the multiple.
Step 3When would you move off the simple average?

When something about the plant or the market has changed. If capacity had grown, older years would need scaling up; if the cost base had fallen permanently, the average understates the future; if the last five years are a better guide to the next five, the Rs 400 crore five-year average is defensible. Including this year in a nine-year average gives Rs 428 crore, and it belongs if the year is nearly complete. What does not belong is an argument that this cycle is different because prices are high now; every peak has that argument attached. Check too whether the 6x is really a mid-cycle multipleA valuation multiple that analysts apply to a normalised, average-over-the-cycle earnings figure rather than to the current year, so that it stays roughly stable as earnings swing.: if peers are priced on this year's earnings at 6x and this year is also their good year, the multiple is already a trough multiple on peak earnings, and applying it to an average would understate.

Close with the view and its limit. Rs 2,512 crore, with a range from the five-year average to the nine-year one, Rs 2,400 crore to Rs 2,567 crore, and a clear note that this year's figure is not a base. The limit of any average is that it assumes the next cycle looks like the last; a plant facing a structural change in its input cost or a new competitor's capacity has a different mid-cycle, and the right number is a forecast, not a history. Say which you are using, because a bid at Rs 3,000 crore is a bet that the next eight years average 500, and nothing in the record supports it.

Where candidates lose it

The usual miss is reaching for this year's Rs 500 crore because it is current, then applying 6x and arriving at Rs 3,000 crore. The 6x is a mid-cycle multiple; applied to a good year it double-counts the cycle, and the buyer overpays by about a fifth.

The second is taking the average without asking whether the plant that earned it is the plant being bought. Capacity, costs and the market change; the average is only a base when the business is roughly the same business through the period.

What the interviewer asks next

  • Tamrav added 20% capacity three years ago. How would you restate the earlier years?
  • Why do cyclical stocks look cheapest on P/E at the top of the cycle?
  • How would you check whether the 6x peer multiple is applied to mid-cycle or to current earnings?
  • A buyer argues a long-term supply contract has removed the cycle. What evidence would you want?
← Case 099A promoter wants to sell 5% of a hospital company, 2.5 crore shares at Rs 600 with daily volume of 30 lakh shares. An overnight block at a 4% discount, or selling 25% of daily volume for about 33 days with an expected 3% impact and 2% daily volatility. Which would you advise?

Company names and figures are illustrative.

Fin Maverick

Finance education that ends in a job, not a certificate that gathers dust. Built for young India.

LEARN
CalculatorsFrameworksComparisonsInterview RoadmapsShowdown
RESOURCES
All CoursesFree CoursesBootcampsNISMQuarksAI for Finance
COMPANY
AboutJob openingPartnership
LEGAL
Privacy PolicyTerms & ConditionsContent LicenseReturn & Refund Policy
© 2026 FIN MAVERICK / BUILT FOR INDIA.DO FINANCE, DO NOT JUST READ ABOUT IT.