Fin Maverick
QuarksCourses
PartnershipsShowdown
Log inSign up
Interview tracksAll
1Investment Banking
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
2Equity Research
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
3Venture Capital
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
4Private Equity
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
5Hedge Funds
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
6Quant
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
7Financial Analysis
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
8Private Wealth Management
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
9Debt Capital Markets
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
10Risk Management
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
11Derivatives Foundation
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
12Portfolio Management
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
13Mutual Fund Mastery
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
002

Case 002Fund selection and due diligenceCore

A wealth platform must put one flexi cap fund on its recommended list. Fund A has the best five-year return but a new manager, Fund B has a long record and lower risk, and Fund C is cheap but moves almost exactly with the index. Which goes on the list?

1The situation

Chandrika Wealth Platform, an invented online distributor, shows one flexi cap fund on its recommended list. The research team has narrowed it to three. The category benchmark returned 14.3% a year over five years with 17% volatility.

Fund A: five-year return 17.1% a year, volatility 19%, current manager in charge for 1 year, AUM Rs 42,000 crore, expense ratio 1.7%, R-squared to the index 0.82. Fund B: 15.2%, 15%, manager tenure 9 years, AUM Rs 8,000 crore, 1.6%, R-squared 0.85. Fund C: 14.0%, 16%, manager tenure 6 years, AUM Rs 3,500 crore, 0.9%, R-squared 0.96.

2Your task

Which fund goes on the list, and what would you say to the head of distribution who wants Fund A because it tops the return table?

Quick check

What is the single biggest problem with Fund A's 17.1%?

Worked solution

Try it on paper, then open one step at a time.

30-second answerThe answer to give first

Fund B goes on the list. It beat the benchmark by 0.9% a year with less volatility than the index, under the same manager for all five years. Fund A's higher return belongs mostly to a manager who has left. Fund C moves 96% with the index yet charges an active fee and lagged the benchmark, so an index fund would do its job more cheaply.

Step 1What is a return table actually telling you?

Imagine choosing a surgeon by a hospital's success rate, then learning the surgeon who built that record retired last year. The number is real; it just no longer describes who will operate on you. A fund's past return is evidence about the people and process that produced it, so the first question is whether those people and that process are still in place. Fund A's current manager has run it for one of the five years in its record. The other four are a different person's work.

Same four questions for three funds: how much of each record can you trust?Fund A5-year return17.1%Volatility19%Years of the 5 run1 of 5Expense ratio1.7%Moves with index (R2)0.82Record belongs to theprevious managerFund B5-year return15.2%Volatility15%Years of the 5 run5 of 5Expense ratio1.6%Moves with index (R2)0.85Goes on the list:long record, less riskFund C5-year return14.0%Volatility16%Years of the 5 run5 of 5Expense ratio0.9%Moves with index (R2)0.96An index fund atan active fee
Fund A has the best five-year return but its current manager ran only one of those five years; Fund B has a lower return, lower volatility and a manager in place for all five; Fund C is cheapest but moves 96% with the index.
Step 2Once risk is counted, how do the returns compare?

Put each return over the volatility it took to earn it. Using an assumed 6.5% risk-free rate, the Sharpe ratioReturn above a risk-free rate, divided by volatility. It measures how much extra return each unit of risk earned. is 0.56 for A, 0.58 for B and 0.47 for C. Once risk is counted, Fund B is at least as good as Fund A, and its record is entirely its current manager's. Fund B also beat the benchmark while being less volatile than it, 15% against 17%, which is the combination a platform wants to put in front of clients who will panic in a fall.

FundReturnAbove indexVolatilitySharpeYears run by manager
Fund A17.1%+2.8%19%0.561 of 5
Fund B15.2%+0.9%15%0.585 of 5
Fund C14.0%-0.3%16%0.475 of 5
Fund A leads on raw return and on return above the index, but on return per unit of risk Fund B edges ahead, and only Funds B and C have a five-year record earned by the manager who runs them today.
Step 3Why not the cheap fund?

Fund C's R-squared of 0.96 means 96% of its month-to-month movement is explained by the index. Paying 0.9% for a fund that is 96% index is paying an active fee for a small active bet, and that bet lost 0.3% a year against the benchmark. Its active risk, about 3.2% a year, is the only part of the fund the fee is buying. An index fund costing a fraction of that would deliver nearly the same portfolio. Fund C is not a bad product; it is the wrong product for a slot meant for active management.

Step 4What do you tell the head of distribution?

Give the reason in one line, then the path back. Fund A stays on the watch list, not the recommended list, until its current manager has built a record of their own, usually three years. Its size is a second question worth raising: Rs 42,000 crore in a flexi cap fund limits how much it can hold in smaller companies, which is often where a flexi cap fund's edge comes from. The limit of this analysis is honest too: five years is a short sample for any fund, and Fund B's lead on risk-adjusted return is small. Its advantage is that its evidence is clean.

Where candidates lose it

The fastest way to lose this case is ranking by the return column and stopping. The interviewer has planted the one-year manager tenure precisely to see whether you ask who earned the number.

The second miss is choosing Fund C because it is cheapest. Cost matters, but a fund that is 96% index is judged against an index fund, and on that comparison it is expensive.

What the interviewer asks next

  • Fund A's new manager came from a fund with a 12-year record of beating its benchmark. Does that change your answer?
  • How would you check whether Fund B's lower volatility came from holding cash?
  • Fund A's AUM doubles next year. What would you expect to happen to its style?
← Case 001Pitch Chitravarna Paints: revenue of Rs 4,200 crore growing 14%, an 18% EBITDA margin, 32% return on capital, net cash, and a share price at 48 times earnings. Long or pass, and what has to be true for 48 times to work?Case 003 →A debt fund is offered A-rated manufacturing bonds paying 250 basis points over AAA. With an assumed 3.5% three-year default rate and 35% recovery, does the spread pay for the risk, and what else must it pay for?

Company names and figures are illustrative.

Fin Maverick

Finance education that ends in a job, not a certificate that gathers dust. Built for young India.

LEARN
CalculatorsFrameworksComparisonsInterview RoadmapsShowdown
RESOURCES
All CoursesFree CoursesBootcampsNISMQuarksAI for Finance
COMPANY
AboutJob openingPartnership
LEGAL
Privacy PolicyTerms & ConditionsContent LicenseReturn & Refund Policy
© 2026 FIN MAVERICK / BUILT FOR INDIA.DO FINANCE, DO NOT JUST READ ABOUT IT.