Case 086Macro and multi-asset scenariosCore
Oil falls 40%. For a pegged oil exporter, trace the effect on the budget, the currency, interest rates and the yield curve, then position a foreign bond portfolio.
1The situation
The Republic of Qamaria, an invented country, pegs its currency to the US dollar. Oil is 30% of GDP, 70% of exports and 60% of government revenue. Government revenue is 25% of GDP and exports are 40% of GDP. Before the shock the budget deficit is 1% of GDP, the current account shows a 3% surplus, and reserves equal about 22.5% of GDP.
The oil price falls 40% and the market expects it to stay low. A global bond fund you help manage holds some of Qamaria's local currency bonds and some of its dollar bonds. One-year dollar deposits pay 4%.
2Your task
Trace the shock through the budget, the currency, rates and the curve. What would you do with the fund's Qamaria bonds?
Quick check
Roughly where does Qamaria's budget deficit go, as a share of pre-shock GDP?
Worked solution
Try it on paper, then open one step at a time.
30-second answerThe answer to give first
The deficit jumps from 1% to about 7% of GDP, the current account swings from a 3% surplus to a 8.2% deficit, and defending the peg forces rate hikes that invert the curve. Reserves drain as dollars stop arriving, so the central bank raises short rates, while long rates rise less because the squeeze points to recession. For the fund: cut local currency bonds, because the extra yield does not pay for a devaluation risk above about 23% a year, and keep dollar exposure short-dated.
Step 1Where does the shock land first?
Picture a household where one earner brings in most of the money and that earner's pay is cut by 40%. The monthly budget breaks, savings start to run down, and the family borrows. Qamaria gets hit through two channels at once: the budget, because oil pays for most of the state, and the external account, because oil brings in most of the dollars. Chain the shares. Oil revenue is 60% of revenue that is 25% of GDP, so 15% of GDP; losing 40% of it widens the deficit by 6 points to 7%. Oil exports are 70% of exports worth 40% of GDP, so 28% of GDP; losing 40% removes 11.2 points and turns the current account from +3% to -8.2%.
Step 2Why does a peg push rates up and invert the curve?
A currency pegA promise by the central bank to hold the exchange rate at a fixed level, which it keeps by buying and selling its reserves. holds only while the central bank can sell dollars to anyone who wants them. With the current account in deficit, fewer dollars arrive; at 8.2% of GDP a year, reserves of 22.5% of GDP last about 2.7 years even before capital runs for the door. To keep money at home the central bank raises short rates sharply, while long rates rise less because investors expect the squeeze to cause a recession and later cuts. The result is a curve where three-month money yields 11.0% and ten-year bonds 8.4%, an inversion of 260 basis points.
Step 3Is the extra yield on local bonds worth taking?
Compare the carry with the cliff. A one-year local bond at 10.4% beats a 4% dollar deposit by about 6.4 points if the peg holds. If the peg breaks, a 25% devaluation is a plausible first step. The local bond breaks even with dollars only if the chance of devaluation within the year is below about 23%. With twin deficits of 7% and 8.2% of GDP and a clock on the reserves, that is not a probability to be confident about.
| Holding | If the peg holds | If it breaks | Action |
|---|---|---|---|
| Local bonds, long | Gain as recession pulls long yields down | Currency loss swamps it | Cut |
| Local bonds, short | Carry of about 6.4 points | Loses if devaluation risk exceeds about 23% | Cut or hedge, if hedging is available |
| Dollar bonds, long | Spread may tighten with a financing deal | Spread widens sharply with the deficit | Reduce |
| Dollar bonds, short | Repaid from reserves | Smaller price loss than long bonds | Keep |
Say what would change the view: a credible spending cut, external financing that rebuilds reserves, or oil recovering. A pegged exporter can hold the line for a while, but the cost of holding it is a recession, and that is what the inverted curve is saying. The limit of this sketch is that it treats every share as fixed; in practice imports fall too, which slows the reserve drain and buys time.
Where candidates lose it
The common loss is saying the currency falls and stopping there. Under a peg the exchange rate does not move at first; the pressure shows up in reserves and interest rates, and the candidate who misses that cannot explain why the curve inverts.
The second is buying the local bonds for their yield. High short rates in a pegged currency under strain are the price of devaluation risk, not a free return.
What the interviewer asks next
- What would you watch week by week to judge whether the peg will hold?
- How does the answer change if Qamaria has a large sovereign wealth fund?
- Why might a devaluation actually help Qamaria's budget?
- Which other countries' bonds would you look at as second-round losers?
Asked at State Street, Equity Research, Boston, 2020 (Wall Street Oasis): How does the dropping oil price impact oil-exporting nations? 2. What is the Yield curve?
Company names and figures are illustrative.
