Case 006Liquidity risk and ALMCore
A payments bank's outgoing payments leave in the morning and its receipts arrive in the afternoon. It ends every day in surplus. Map its intraday position, find the peak shortfall and fix it.
1The situation
Ravisto Payments Bank settles customer and merchant payments through the central bank's real-time gross settlement system. On a typical heavy day it sends Rs 700 crore between 10 and 11 am and Rs 500 crore between 11 am and noon. It receives Rs 300 crore between noon and 2 pm and Rs 950 crore after 2 pm, mostly from two large merchant acquirers.
Ravisto holds Rs 400 crore of intraday liquidity: its settlement account balance plus what it can raise immediately. Assume payments flow evenly within each window. Whether and on what terms the central bank provides intraday credit against securities is an illustrative framework here; confirm the current facility before relying on it.
2Your task
Map Ravisto's position through the day, find the peak shortfall and propose how to close it.
Quick check
Ravisto ends the day Rs 50 crore in surplus. What is its largest shortfall during the day?
Worked solution
Try it on paper, then open one step at a time.
30-second answerThe answer to give first
Ravisto's position bottoms at minus Rs 1,200 crore at noon, a shortfall of Rs 800 crore after its Rs 400 crore buffer, even though it ends the day Rs 50 crore up. The buffer runs out at about 10:34. Moving the Rs 500 crore noon batch after 2 pm cuts the shortfall to Rs 300 crore, and intraday credit against government securities can cover the rest.
Step 1How can a bank that ends the day in surplus be short?
Think of a shop that pays its suppliers in cash every morning and receives its card sales in the afternoon. It can end every day in profit and still be unable to pay the morning delivery if the till is empty at ten. Payment systems settle one payment at a time, in real time, so a bank needs the cash when each payment leaves, not on average over the day. This is intraday liquidity riskThe risk that a bank cannot make a payment at the moment it is due, even if the day nets to a surplus., and the end-of-day figure is blind to it.
Step 2What does the hour-by-hour map show?
Add the flows in order. By 11 am Ravisto is minus Rs 700 crore; by noon minus Rs 1,200 crore. The Rs 300 crore of midday receipts bring it to minus Rs 900 crore at 2 pm, and the afternoon Rs 950 crore takes it to plus Rs 50 crore at close. With Rs 400 crore of buffer, Ravisto runs out at about 10:34 and is Rs 800 crore short at noon. Payments queue, merchants are not paid on time, and if the queue is not cleared, the bank has failed to settle.
| Time | Cumulative flows | With Rs 400 crore buffer | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 am | +0 | +400 | Covered |
| 11 am | -700 | -300 | Short |
| Noon | -1,200 | -800 | Short |
| 2 pm | -900 | -500 | Short |
| Close | +50 | +450 | Covered |
Step 3How would you close the gap?
Start with timing, because it is free. If the Rs 500 crore noon batch can wait until after 2 pm, the low improves from minus Rs 1,200 crore to minus Rs 700 crore and the shortfall falls to Rs 300 crore. That batch must be payments that can legally and commercially wait, such as scheduled merchant settlements, not customer transfers promised in real time. The remaining Rs 300 crore can come from intraday credit against government securities, so Ravisto needs at least that much eligible collateral, after haircuts, unencumbered each morning.
Then stress the inflows, because they are concentrated. If the Rs 950 crore from the two acquirers slips past the settlement cut-off, Ravisto closes at minus Rs 500 crore after its buffer, an overnight problem, not an intraday one. Ask the acquirers to settle earlier or in tranches, monitor the position in real time against an internal trigger, and report the daily peak usage to the asset-liability committee. The limitation: the even-flow assumption smooths the day, and real payment traffic comes in bursts that make the peak worse.
Where candidates lose it
Candidates look at the end-of-day surplus and declare Ravisto liquid. The question is designed so the daily total is positive precisely to see whether you ask when the money moves.
The second miss is quoting the Rs 1,200 crore gross outflow as the shortfall and forgetting the buffer, or proposing more buffer as the only fix when free rescheduling closes most of the gap.
What the interviewer asks next
- One acquirer's Rs 500 crore arrives at 6 pm, after cut-off. What happens overnight?
- How would you set an early-warning trigger on intraday usage?
- Why do payment systems offer liquidity-saving queues, and what risk do they create?
Company names and figures are illustrative.
