Fin Maverick
QuarksCourses
PartnershipsShowdown
Log inSign up
Interview tracksAll
1Investment Banking
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
2Equity Research
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
3Venture Capital
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
4Private Equity
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
5Hedge Funds
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
6Quant
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
7Financial Analysis
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
8Private Wealth Management
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
9Debt Capital Markets
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
10Risk Management
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
11Derivatives Foundation
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
12Portfolio Management
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
13Mutual Fund Mastery
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
030

Case 030Capital structure decisionsCore

Kirtiman Infra can fund Rs 500 crore of capex with senior bonds at 8.6% or a perpetual hybrid at 10.5% that the rating agency gives 50% equity credit. Which keeps its rating, and at what cost?

1The situation

Kirtiman Infra builds and operates bulk material handling terminals. EBITDA is Rs 800 crore and debt Rs 3,000 crore, 3.75x. Its rating agency has said the rating would come under pressure if adjusted debt rose above 4.25x EBITDA. It needs Rs 500 crore for new terminals, which will earn nothing for two years.

Option one is a senior bond at 8.6%. Option two is a perpetual subordinated hybrid at 10.5%, callable after year 5, with the coupon stepping up by 100 basis points if it is not called. The agency has indicated it would treat half the hybrid as equity.

2Your task

Compare adjusted leverage under each option, put a price on the rating headroom, and say what the step-up means for how long the headroom lasts.

Quick check

With the hybrid, what adjusted leverage does the agency see?

Worked solution

Try it on paper, then open one step at a time.

30-second answerThe answer to give first

The hybrid keeps Kirtiman under the line at 4.06x; senior bonds would take it to 4.38x and invite a downgrade. The headroom costs 1.9 percentage points on Rs 500 crore, about Rs 9.5 crore a year more than senior debt, and it is cheaper than raising half the money as equity. The step-up makes the hybrid a five-year instrument in practice, so the headroom must be replaced by then.

Step 1What is a hybrid buying, in plain terms?

A family that borrows from a relative on the understanding that repayment waits until the children finish school has more cushion than one with a bank loan due every month. A hybridA security between debt and equity: it pays a coupon like a bond but is deeply subordinated, can defer payments and has no fixed maturity, so agencies treat part of it as equity. buys rating headroom by being loss-absorbing enough that the agency counts part of it as equity. Kirtiman pays a higher coupon for that privilege, because hybrid investors rank behind every senior lender and can have coupons deferred.

Step 2What leverage does the agency see under each option?

Senior bonds add the full Rs 500 crore: Rs 3,500 crore on Rs 800 crore is 4.38x, over the 4.25x line. The hybrid adds only Rs 250 crore to adjusted debt, giving 4.06x, because the agency moves the other half into equity. The headroom bought is 0.31 turns of leverage. On Kirtiman's own balance sheet the accounting may differ again, since classification follows the terms of the instrument; confirm the treatment with the auditors and the agency's current criteria.

The agency counts half the hybrid as equity, which keeps Kirtiman under its lineDebt 3,000Today3.75x EBITDADebt 3,000Senior 500Rs 500 cr senior bond4.38x EBITDADebt 3,000Debt half 250Rs 500 cr hybrid4.06x EBITDAEquity half250, not debtdowngrade line 4.25x = Rs 3,400 cr
Against the agency's 4.25x line, Kirtiman sits at 3.75x today, would reach 4.38x funding with Rs 500 crore of senior bonds, and reaches only 4.06x with the hybrid because half of it counts as equity.
Step 3What does the headroom cost, and is there a cheaper way to buy it?

The hybrid costs Rs 52.5 crore a year against Rs 43.0 crore for senior debt, so the rating headroom costs about Rs 9.5 crore a year. The alternative that gives the same adjusted leverage is Rs 250 crore of senior debt and Rs 250 crore of new equity. At an assumed 14% cost of equity that mix costs about Rs 56.5 crore a year, and it dilutes existing shareholders permanently. Whether the coupon is tax deductible depends on how the instrument is classified; confirm the current tax position before comparing after-tax costs.

Cost a year of each way to raise Rs 500 crore, Rs croreSenior bond, 8.6%43.0, breaks the 4.25x linePerpetual hybrid, 10.5%52.5, keeps the ratingHalf senior, half equity at 14%56.5, keeps it tooThe rating headroom costs Rs 9.5 crore a year over senior debt
Raising Rs 500 crore costs Rs 43.0 crore a year in senior bonds but breaks the rating line, Rs 52.5 crore as a hybrid, and about Rs 56.5 crore as half senior debt and half equity at an assumed 14% cost of equity.
Step 4Why does the step-up matter?

If Kirtiman does not call in year 5 the coupon rises to 11.5%, a penalty every investor expects it to avoid. A step-up turns a perpetual into a five-year instrument in everyone's eyes, and agencies know it, so the equity credit is only as durable as the plan to replace the hybrid. The view: use the hybrid, because the new terminals will be earning by year 3 and leverage should fall back under 4.0x by year 5, when the hybrid can be called and refinanced with senior debt without breaching the line.

Where candidates lose it

The usual miss is treating the hybrid as either all debt or all equity. The agency's 50% credit is the whole point: it moves Rs 250 crore, not Rs 500 crore and not nothing.

The second is calling the hybrid permanent capital. The step-up makes a call at year 5 close to certain, so the headroom is borrowed for five years, and the plan must show leverage falling by then.

What the interviewer asks next

  • What happens to the equity credit if the agency concludes Kirtiman will certainly call at year 5?
  • Why do hybrid investors accept coupon deferral, and what do they demand for it?
  • If EBITDA from the new terminals is two years late, what are Kirtiman's options at the call date?
← Case 029Olvara Textiles asks for a Rs 150 crore five-year term loan on EBITDA of Rs 110 crore and existing debt of Rs 260 crore. Is it creditworthy for this loan?Case 031 →Lakshaka Power's bonds trade at 80. It plans to spend Rs 160 crore of cash buying back Rs 200 crore of face value in the market. What does it gain, what happens to leverage, and what liquidity does it give up?

Company names and figures are illustrative.

Fin Maverick

Finance education that ends in a job, not a certificate that gathers dust. Built for young India.

LEARN
CalculatorsFrameworksComparisonsInterview RoadmapsShowdown
RESOURCES
All CoursesFree CoursesBootcampsNISMQuarksAI for Finance
COMPANY
AboutJob openingPartnership
LEGAL
Privacy PolicyTerms & ConditionsContent LicenseReturn & Refund Policy
© 2026 FIN MAVERICK / BUILT FOR INDIA.DO FINANCE, DO NOT JUST READ ABOUT IT.