Case 031Liability management and refinancingWarm up
Lakshaka Power's bonds trade at 80. It plans to spend Rs 160 crore of cash buying back Rs 200 crore of face value in the market. What does it gain, what happens to leverage, and what liquidity does it give up?
1The situation
Lakshaka Power runs a captive power plant selling to industrial customers. EBITDA is Rs 250 crore. It has Rs 1,000 crore of 8% bonds with four years to run and a Rs 200 crore bank loan due in 15 months, which the bank has said it will roll only against a credible plan. Cash is Rs 300 crore, earning about 6%.
A customer dispute has pushed the bonds down to 80. The board wants to use Rs 160 crore of cash to buy back Rs 200 crore of bonds in the open market.
2Your task
Work out the gain, the effect on gross and net leverage, and the effect on liquidity, and give the board a view.
Quick check
By how much does net debt fall after the buyback?
Worked solution
Try it on paper, then open one step at a time.
30-second answerThe answer to give first
Lakshaka captures a Rs 40 crore discount and cuts gross leverage from 4.8x to 4.0x, but net leverage barely moves, 3.60x to 3.44x, and cash falls to Rs 140 crore. That leaves Rs 60 crore short of the bank loan due in 15 months. Retiring bonds at a 15% yield is attractive, but only after the bank loan is refinanced, or in a smaller size that keeps a cash buffer.
Step 1Where does the gain come from?
Suppose you owe a friend Rs 1,000 and he, short of money, offers to take Rs 800 today and call it settled. You are Rs 200 better off, but you have spent Rs 800 you may have needed. A discounted buyback turns the market's doubt about the borrower into a gain for the borrower's shareholders: Rs 200 crore of claims retired for Rs 160 crore. The Rs 40 crore gain is real for equity. It usually shows up as accounting income and may be taxable; confirm the treatment before quoting an after-tax figure.
Step 2What does the buyback do to leverage?
Gross debt falls from Rs 1,200 crore to Rs 1,000 crore, 4.8x to 4.0x EBITDA, which is the number the headline will quote. Net debt falls only from Rs 900 crore to Rs 860 crore, because the cash that paid for the bonds was already netted against them. The net leverageDebt minus cash, divided by EBITDA. Spending cash to repay debt leaves it unchanged except for any discount captured. improvement is 0.16x, exactly the discount. Interest falls by Rs 16 crore a year while lost interest on cash is about Rs 9.6 crore, a net saving of Rs 6.4 crore.
Step 3What liquidity does it give up, and what would you tell the board?
Look at the next maturity, not at the balance sheet. Before the buyback Rs 300 crore of cash covers the Rs 200 crore bank loan with Rs 100 crore spare; after it, Rs 140 crore leaves a Rs 60 crore hole, and the bank has already said it wants a plan before it rolls. A company whose bonds trade at 80 may find refinancing dear or unavailable, which is exactly why the bonds trade there.
The view: retiring debt at 80 is buying back Lakshaka's own paper at about a 15% yield to maturity, better than any other use of the cash. But sequence matters. Refinance or extend the bank loan first, then buy back; until then, cap the spend at about Rs 50 crore, which retires about Rs 62.5 crore of face and keeps a buffer. Also check the bond documents: some restrict buybacks or require an offer to all holders, and bondholders who did not sell may read the buyback as the company spending their cushion.
Where candidates lose it
The common slip is announcing that leverage fell from 4.8x to 4.0x. Gross leverage did, but the cash spent was already counted against the debt, so net leverage moved by only the discount.
The second is ignoring the calendar. A buyback that leaves the company unable to repay a loan due in 15 months swaps a cheap gain for a refinancing crisis, and interviewers want to hear the maturity named.
What the interviewer asks next
- Why might bondholders who did not sell object to the buyback?
- Would a tender offer to all holders at 82 be better than open market purchases?
- How would your advice change if the bonds traded at 95?
- What is the tax position of the Rs 40 crore gain, and where would you confirm it?
Company names and figures are illustrative.
