Case 083Estate, succession and trustsCore
In a Rs 20 crore family trust portfolio, one stock has risen to 13% against a 10% cap in the investment policy. Describe the fiduciary's day-to-day steps: detect the breach, decide the trade, document the reason and report to the beneficiaries.
1The situation
You are the professional trustee's investment officer for the Vashisht family trust, which holds Rs 20 crore for the income of a widow and, later, the capital of her three children. The trust's investment policy statement caps any single company at 10% of the portfolio and asks for a breach to be cured within 30 days unless the trustees record a reason not to.
After a strong run, one listed stock, Stock V, is worth Rs 2.6 crore, 13% of the trust. It was bought for Rs 90 lakh. Use an illustrative 12.5% tax on long-term gains, and note that trust taxation must be confirmed with the trust's tax adviser.
2Your task
Walk through what you do from the morning the breach shows up to the report the beneficiaries receive.
Quick check
How much of Stock V must be sold to bring it back to exactly 10%, with the proceeds kept in the trust?
Worked solution
Try it on paper, then open one step at a time.
30-second answerThe answer to give first
Detect it on the daily check, decide within days, sell about Rs 80 lakh to a 9% buffer, and record why before reporting it. Rs 60 lakh would reach exactly 10%, but a buffer stops the next rise from breaching again. The sale realises about Rs 52 lakh of gain, roughly Rs 6.5 lakh of illustrative tax. Most fiduciary work is exactly this: monitoring against a written limit and leaving a record a beneficiary could audit.
Step 1What does a fiduciary actually do on an ordinary day?
Checks the portfolio against rules written before anyone knew the prices. Think of a guardian holding a child's savings: nobody judges her on one great pick, only on whether she kept to the promises made when the money was handed over. A fiduciaryA person bound to act in the interest of someone else, putting their interest before his own, with a duty of care and a duty of loyalty. spends most days monitoring holdings against the investment policy, making the few decisions the policy calls for, and writing down why. The trades are rare; the record is constant.
Step 2How is the breach detected, and what kind of breach is it?
A daily limit report flags any holding over its cap, and many trusts also set an early-warning level, here 9%, so the trustees see a breach coming. This one is a passive breach: nobody bought more of Stock V, its price rose. That matters, because a passive breach is handled on a timetable with a recorded judgement, while an active breach, a purchase that broke the limit, is reversed at once and investigated.
Step 3How much should be sold, and why not exactly back to 10%?
Do the arithmetic both ways the interviewer might mean. With the proceeds reinvested inside the trust, the total stays Rs 20 crore, so returning to 10% needs a Rs 60 lakh sale. Selling to exactly 10% invites another breach next month; selling to a 9% buffer, Rs 80 lakh, leaves room for normal price moves. The sale realises about Rs 52 lakh of gain. The tax is real, but the limit exists to protect the widow's income and the children's capital from one company's fortunes, which outweighs a tax the trust would pay eventually anyway.
| 2.6 | Stock V today, Rs crore |
| 20 | trust value, unchanged because the proceeds are reinvested |
| 0.09 | the buffer below the 10% cap |
| x | amount of Stock V to sell |
Step 4What goes in the record and the report?
The limit, the reading, the cause, the options considered, the decision, who approved it and the tax cost. The record is written so that a beneficiary, or a court, reading it five years later can see the trustees followed the policy and weighed each party's interest. The widow gains nothing from keeping the concentration and her children bear most of its risk; recording that impartiality is part of the duty. The quarterly letter then states the breach, the cure and its cost in plain words.
Where candidates lose it
Candidates describe fiduciary duty in abstract words, loyalty, prudence, care, and never get to the mechanics. The question asks what happens day to day; the answer is monitoring, a timed decision and a record.
The second miss is the arithmetic: dividing by the smaller total gives Rs 66.7 lakh, which is right only if the proceeds leave the trust. Say which case you are in.
What the interviewer asks next
- The widow's son asks the trustees to keep Stock V because his father founded the company. How do you respond?
- What would you do differently if the trust's deed allowed the trustees to hold it?
- How would the answer change if the breach were active, caused by a purchase?
Asked at BNY Mellon, Private Wealth Management, New York, 2022 (Wall Street Oasis): Describe what a fiduciary does on a day-to-day basis
Company names and figures are illustrative.
