Case 098Term sheets and waterfallsCore
Chitravik Studio raised Rs 3 crore on a SAFE with a Rs 30 crore post-money cap and a 20% discount. The Series A prices the company at Rs 80 crore pre-money with Rs 20 crore raised. Does the cap or the discount apply, and what does the SAFE holder own after the round? What changes if the Series A is at Rs 30 crore pre-money?
1The situation
Chitravik Studio makes animation software for small video studios. The founders own all 90 lakh shares. A year ago an angel invested Rs 3 crore on a SAFE, a simple agreement for future equity: the money converts into shares at the next priced round, at the lower of two prices. One is the cap price, set so that the SAFE converts into 10% of the company (Rs 3 crore of a Rs 30 crore post-money cap) before the new round. The other is the new round's price less a 20% discount.
A Series A investor now offers Rs 20 crore at an Rs 80 crore pre-money valuation. Assume the pre-money is measured on all shares including the SAFE's converted shares, and there is no option pool.
2Your task
Decide whether the cap or the discount applies, and work out the SAFE holder's ownership after the round. Then redo it with a Series A at Rs 30 crore pre-money.
Quick check
At an Rs 80 crore pre-money, which price does the SAFE convert at?
Worked solution
Try it on paper, then open one step at a time.
30-second answerThe answer to give first
At an Rs 80 crore pre-money the cap applies and the SAFE holder owns 8.0% after the round; at Rs 30 crore the discount applies and it owns 7.5%. The cap price is Rs 30 a share; the Rs 80 round less 20% is Rs 64, so Rs 3 crore buys 10 lakh shares, worth Rs 8 crore at the round price. At Rs 30 crore pre the discounted price, Rs 23.33, is below Rs 30, so the discount wins.
Step 1How does a SAFE choose its price?
Imagine you pre-booked a flat with a builder who promised you either 20% off the launch price or a ceiling price, whichever is better for you. If the launch price is high, the ceiling protects you; if it is low, the discount does. A SAFESimple agreement for future equity: money given now that converts into shares at the next priced round, usually at a capped valuation or a discount to the round price. works the same way: it converts at the lower of the cap price and the discounted round price, because a lower price buys more shares. So compute both and take the lower.
Step 2What happens at an Rs 80 crore pre-money?
The cap price first. A Rs 30 crore post-money cap on a Rs 3 crore SAFE means the SAFE becomes 10% of the company before the round: 10 lakh new shares beside the founders' 90 lakh, at Rs 30 a share. The round price is Rs 80 crore over 1 crore shares, Rs 80 a share, and 20% off is Rs 64. Rs 30 is lower, so the cap applies. The Series A's Rs 20 crore buys 25 lakh shares. After the round there are 1.25 crore shares: founders 72%, SAFE 8%, Series A 20%. The SAFE's 10 lakh shares are worth Rs 8 crore at the round price.
Step 3What changes at an Rs 30 crore pre-money?
Now the round price is low. The pre-money includes the SAFE's shares, and their number depends on the price, so solve the two together: the round price P times all shares before the new money equals Rs 30 crore, with the SAFE converting at 0.8P. That gives a round price of Rs 29.17 and a discounted price of Rs 23.33, below the Rs 30 cap price, so the discount applies. Rs 3 crore at Rs 23.33 buys 12.86 lakh shares. The Series A's Rs 20 crore buys 68.57 lakh shares. After the round: founders 52.5%, SAFE 7.5%, Series A 40.0%.
| P | Series A price per share, Rs |
| 90 | lakh founder shares |
| 3 crore / 0.8P | SAFE shares at the discounted price |
| 30 crore | pre-money, including the SAFE's shares |
| Rs 80 crore pre | Rs 30 crore pre | |
|---|---|---|
| Series A price per share | Rs 80.00 | Rs 29.17 |
| SAFE conversion price | Rs 30.00 (cap) | Rs 23.33 (discount) |
| SAFE shares, lakh | 10.00 | 12.86 |
| Series A shares, lakh | 25.00 | 68.57 |
| Founders after | 72.0% | 52.5% |
| SAFE after | 8.0% | 7.5% |
| Series A after | 20.0% | 40.0% |
| SAFE value at round price, Rs crore | 8.00 | 3.75 |
Step 4What should founders and angels take from this?
The cap and the discount give the same price when the round price is Rs 30 divided by 0.8, Rs 37.50, an Rs 37.5 crore pre-money. Above that the cap protects the angel and the founders give up more than the discount alone would cost them; below it the discount sets the price. In the high case the angel's Rs 3 crore is worth Rs 8 crore at the round price, which is the reward for funding early. Founders should model the cap's dilution before signing, because it is fixed at 10% however well the company does. The limit: real SAFE documents differ on whether the option pool and other SAFEs count in the capitalisation, so read the definitions in the actual document.
Where candidates lose it
Candidates apply the discount because it sounds like the main term, getting Rs 64 a share and under 5 lakh SAFE shares in the high case. The SAFE always takes the lower price, and at an Rs 80 crore pre-money that is the Rs 30 cap.
The second miss, in the low case, is ignoring that the SAFE's shares sit inside the pre-money. Setting the round price at Rs 30 crore over 90 lakh shares, Rs 33.33, gives a wrong discounted price; solve the price and the SAFE's shares together.
What the interviewer asks next
- The SAFE had a pre-money cap of Rs 30 crore instead. How would the high case change?
- The Series A requires a 10% option pool inside the pre-money. Who bears the dilution?
- Two SAFEs with different caps convert in the same round. How do you handle the circularity?
- Why might an angel accept a discount-only SAFE with no cap?
Company names and figures are illustrative.
