Fin Maverick
Foundations VocabularyAccounting & ReportingEconomics & MacroQuant Methods & ProgrammingBusiness & Company AnalysisCorporate Finance & ValuationBehavioural Finance
Banking & Market InfrastructureFixed Income & RatesDerivatives & Structured ProductsPublic EquitiesTransactions & DealsPortfolio ConstructionFunds & AMCs
Private Markets & AlternativesRisk, Treasury & ControlAI & Digital FinanceStochastic Calculus & PricingWealth & Personal FinanceIndian Markets & RegulationProfessional Practice
CalculatorComparison
Frameworks
Explore Bootcamps
Equity ResearchPortfolio ManagementMutual Fund MasteryInvestment Banking Analyst
Private Equity AnalystQuant & Hedge Fund AnalystBreaking Into VCFinancial Analyst Program
Risk Management ProgramPrivate Wealth ManagementDebt Capital MarketsDerivatives Foundation
Explore Free Courses

Equity Research6

Writing an Investment ThesisBuilding a Discounted Cash FlowReading an Annual Report FastReading a Sector Before a CompanySpotting Quality of Earnings Red FlagsBuilding a Revenue Forecast From Drivers

Portfolio Management3

Rebalancing: When, Why and What It CostsStrategic and Tactical Asset AllocationMeasuring Risk in a Portfolio

Mutual Fund Mastery3

Comparing Funds Without Being FooledHow a NAV Is Struck and Which Day You GetReading a Fund Factsheet Properly

Derivatives Unlocked4

Hedging a Real ExposureThe Greeks, PracticallyFutures, the Basis and What Moves ItReading an Option Payoff

AI For Finance2

Retrieval and Grounding for FinanceDocument Extraction in Finance

Breaking Into Quants4

Backtesting a StrategyHypothesis TestingCleaning Financial DataRegression for Finance

Breaking Into VC3

Sizing a MarketReading a Term Sheet as a FounderHow a Venture Round Actually Works

Financial Analyst Program4

Common Size and Trend AnalysisReading a Cash Flow StatementRatio Analysis That Says SomethingBuilding a Working Capital Schedule

Risk Management Program2

Credit Exposure and How It Is ReducedValue at Risk and What It Hides

Investment Banking Analyst3

Precedent Transactions and Why They DifferReading a Term Sheet StructurallyBuilding a Comparable Companies Table

Private Wealth Management3

Tax Aware Portfolio DecisionsBuilding a Client Risk ProfileGoal Based Planning Arithmetic

Debt Capital Markets3

Analysing an Issuer's CreditDuration and What It Does Not Tell YouBond Pricing and Yield Mechanics

Private Equity Analyst2

Fund Waterfalls and CarryThe LBO in Structure

Hedge Funds Analyst2

Short Selling MechanicsLong Short Mechanics
QuarksCourses
Explore Interview Preparation
Investment BankingEquity ResearchVenture CapitalistPrivate EquityHedge Funds
QuantFinancial AnalysisPrivate Wealth ManagementDebt Capital MarketsRisk Management
Derivatives FoundationPortfolio ManagementMutual Fund Mastery
PartnershipsShowdown
Log inSign up
Interview tracksAll
1Investment Banking
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
2Equity Research
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
3Venture Capital
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
4Private Equity
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
5Hedge Funds
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
6Quant
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
7Financial Analysis
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
8Private Wealth Management
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
9Debt Capital Markets
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
10Risk Management
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
11Derivatives Foundation
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
12Portfolio Management
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
13Mutual Fund Mastery
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
029

Case 029Margin, clearing and risk limitsCore

A clearing member defaults and closing out its book loses Rs 70 crore. Its initial margin is Rs 40 crore and its default fund contribution Rs 10 crore; the clearing corporation holds Rs 5 crore of its own capital in the waterfall and the other members' default fund is Rs 100 crore. Who bears what?

1The situation

A trading member of Chakrata Clearing Corporation fails to meet a margin call after a sharp move and is declared in default. The clearing corporation takes over the member's open positions and closes them out over two days. By the time the book is flat, the close-out has cost Rs 70 crore more than the collateral the member had posted as variation margin.

The member had Rs 40 crore of initial margin with the clearing corporation and Rs 10 crore in the default fund. Chakrata's rulebook puts Rs 5 crore of the clearing corporation's own capital into the waterfall after the defaulter's resources, and the other members' default fund contributions total Rs 100 crore.

2Your task

Walk the Rs 70 crore through the default waterfall in order, say who bears how much, and explain what the surviving members can expect next.

Quick check

After the defaulter's own margin and default fund contribution are used, who pays next?

Worked solution

Try it on paper, then open one step at a time.

30-second answerThe answer to give first

The defaulter's own resources cover Rs 50 crore, the clearing corporation loses Rs 5 crore, and the surviving members lose Rs 15 crore, 15% of their Rs 100 crore fund. The order is fixed by the rulebook: initial margin, then the defaulter's default fund contribution, then the clearing corporation's own capital, then the mutual fund. The loss stops 15% into the mutual layer, so survivors will be asked to top their contributions back up.

Step 1Why is there an order at all?

Picture a housing society with a shared repair fund. If one flat floods the building, the owner's own deposit goes first, then the society's reserve, then a levy on every other flat. Nobody would join a society that levied the neighbours before touching the culprit's deposit. A clearing corporation's default waterfall is that same order written into a rulebook: the defaulter pays first, the house pays next, and the survivors pay last, so that each layer has a reason to keep the one before it adequate. The initial marginCollateral a member posts against the possible loss on its positions over the time it would take to close them out. is sized for a normal close-out; the layers behind it exist for the day the close-out is worse than normal.

Step 2How does Rs 70 crore fall through the layers?

Take the layers in order and stop when the loss is covered. The defaulter's Rs 40 crore of initial margin absorbs the first Rs 40 crore, its Rs 10 crore default fund contribution the next Rs 10 crore, so the defaulter has paid Rs 50 crore and Rs 20 crore remains. Chakrata's own Rs 5 crore goes next, leaving Rs 15 crore. The surviving members' Rs 100 crore fund covers that, so Rs 15 crore is drawn from it and Rs 85 crore is untouched. Each survivor loses in proportion to its contribution: a member that funded 8% of the Rs 100 crore loses Rs 1.2 crore.

A Rs 70 crore loss falls through the layers in order, Rs croreDefaulter's initial marginlayer size Rs 40 crore40 usedDefaulter's default fundlayer size Rs 10 crore10 usedClearing corporation's own capitallayer size Rs 5 crore5 usedOther members' default fundlayer size Rs 100 crore15 used15% of the mutual fund85 untouchedloss stops here: Rs 70 croreDefaulter pays first (red), the clearing house next (pine), survivors last (green)
The Rs 70 crore close-out loss uses all Rs 40 crore of the defaulter's initial margin and all Rs 10 crore of its default fund contribution, then Chakrata's own Rs 5 crore, and stops Rs 15 crore into the surviving members' Rs 100 crore fund, 15% of it.
Layer, in orderSize, Rs croreUsed, Rs croreWho bears it
Defaulter's initial margin4040The defaulter
Defaulter's default fund1010The defaulter
Clearing corporation's own capital55Chakrata's shareholders
Other members' default fund10015Surviving members, pro rata, 15% each
Total70
The Rs 70 crore loss allocated layer by layer; the defaulter bears Rs 50 crore, the clearing corporation Rs 5 crore and the survivors Rs 15 crore.
Step 3What happens to the survivors next?

Three things, and candidates usually name only the first. The survivors are asked to replenish the fund to Rs 100 crore, so their Rs 15 crore loss is realised now and their contribution is restored within days. Second, the rulebook usually caps how much more a survivor can be assessed after a default, often a multiple of its contribution, and in a loss beyond that the clearing corporation moves to recovery tools such as haircutting variation margin gains; confirm the current rulebook before quoting a figure. Third, the risk team reviews why a Rs 40 crore margin was short by Rs 30 crore on a Rs 70 crore close-out: either the margin model's assumed move or its assumed close-out time was too small for this book, and that review is where the real work starts.

State the limit. The waterfall shows who pays on this loss; it does not show whether Rs 5 crore of own capital is enough to make the clearing corporation careful, or whether a default fund of Rs 100 crore would survive two large members failing in the same week, which is the scenario regulators size the fund to. A good close says the mechanics worked here because the loss was 1.75 times the margin, and asks what the fund would have looked like at three times.

Where candidates lose it

The common loss is skipping the clearing corporation's own slice and sending Rs 20 crore straight to the surviving members. The house's capital sits before the mutual fund on purpose; a candidate who misses it has not understood why members accept mutualised losses at all.

The second is stopping at the allocation. The interviewer wants the next step: survivors replenish, their further liability is capped, and the margin model that let a Rs 40 crore margin face a Rs 70 crore close-out goes under review.

What the interviewer asks next

  • The close-out loss is Rs 160 crore instead of Rs 70 crore. Walk the waterfall again and say what the clearing corporation does once the mutual fund is exhausted.
  • Why do clearing corporations hold the defaulter's initial margin separately from its default fund contribution if both are used first?
  • How does a clearing corporation size the default fund, and what is a cover-two standard?
  • A surviving member argues its contribution should not be used because it never traded with the defaulter. What is the answer?
← Case 028A fund sells Satpura 50 index variance at 16 and buys variance on its ten equal-weight constituents at 28. Realised comes in at 14 for the index and 30 for each stock. What correlation was implied, what was realised, and where did the P&L come from?Case 030 →A fund buys five-year protection on Rs 50 crore of Jharsa Minerals bonds. The market spread is 350 bp, the standard running coupon 100 bp and the risky annuity 4.2. What is paid upfront, what is paid each quarter, and who pays whom?

Company names and figures are illustrative.

Fin Maverick Free CoursesExplore Free Courses
Fin Maverick BootcampsExplore Bootcamps
Fin Maverick

Finance education that ends in a job, not a certificate that gathers dust. Built for young India.

LEARN
CalculatorsFrameworksComparisonsInterview RoadmapsShowdown
RESOURCES
All CoursesFree CoursesBootcampsInternships
COMPANY
AboutJob openingPartnership
LEGAL
Privacy PolicyTerms & ConditionsContent LicenseReturn & Refund Policy
© 2026 FIN MAVERICK / BUILT FOR INDIA.DO FINANCE, DO NOT JUST READ ABOUT IT.