Fin Maverick
QuarksCourses
PartnershipsShowdown
Log inSign up
Interview tracksAll
1Investment Banking
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
2Equity Research
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
3Venture Capital
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
4Private Equity
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
5Hedge Funds
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
6Quant
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
7Financial Analysis
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
8Private Wealth Management
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
9Debt Capital Markets
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
10Risk Management
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
11Derivatives Foundation
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
12Portfolio Management
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
13Mutual Fund Mastery
Question bankPuzzlesCase studies
015

Case 015Lump-sum allocationCore

In a group assessment, four candidates get 30 minutes and a data pack on an entrepreneur with Rs 40 crore and five candidate funds, and must agree a portfolio. What structure does a strong group follow, and what portfolio should it reach?

UBSSão Paulo · 2026

1The situation

Tejomay Rao, 46, has sold most of his logistics company and holds Rs 40 crore after tax. He spends about Rs 1.2 crore a year, expects to put Rs 8 crore into a new venture within two years, and says he can live with a fall of up to 20% in the money he will not need for a decade. Four candidates get this profile, a table of five funds and thirty minutes to agree one portfolio and present it.

The data pack, five-year illustrative figures: Fund A, large-cap index, return 12.0%, volatility 15%, cost 0.20%, worst fall 25%. Fund B, flexi-cap active, 14.5%, 17%, 1.00%, worst fall 30%. Fund C, small-cap active, 21.0%, 26%, 0.90%, worst fall 45%. Fund D, short-duration debt, 7.2%, 2%, 0.40%, worst fall 1%. Fund E, arbitrage, 6.6%, 0.8%, 0.35%, no fall.

2Your task

Lay out how the group should use its thirty minutes, and the portfolio the numbers support.

Quick check

What should the group settle before comparing the five funds?

Worked solution

Try it on paper, then open one step at a time.

30-second answerThe answer to give first

Clarify for five minutes, compute for ten, agree for ten, present for five, and let the client's needs set most of the answer. Put the Rs 8 crore venture money in Fund E and two years of spending plus the long-term debt, Rs 12.8 crore, in Fund D. Put Rs 19.2 crore in equity: Rs 10 crore in A, Rs 6.8 crore in B and Rs 2.4 crore in C. A worst-case fall costs the long-term money about -19%, inside his 20% limit.

Step 1What are the assessors actually scoring?

Two things at once: the portfolio and the way four strangers reached it. A kitchen with four cooks and one order does best when someone reads the ticket aloud, the jobs are split, and one person plates. In a group case the structure is scored as much as the answer: who clarifies the brief, whether the group uses the data, how disagreements are settled, and whether one clear recommendation comes out. Talking most is not the same as leading; the candidate who proposes the time plan and brings a quiet member in is usually the one remembered.

Thirty minutes, four blocks: the structure is scored as much as the answerClarify5 minNeeds: Rs 1.2 cr ayear, Rs 8 cr in 2years, 20% loss limitCompute10 minReserves first: Rs 8 crventure, Rs 2.4 crspending; test the 20%limit on the restAgree10 minOne owner per sleeve;reject chasing Fund C's21%: past return isnot the planPresent5 minOne voice, oneslide: needs,portfolio, risksThe portfolio the data supports, Rs crore (total 40)A 10.0B 6.8C 2.4D 12.8E 8.0Equity A+B+C = 19.2 (48%); debt D = 12.8; venture reserve E = 8.0. Worst-case fall on the long-term money: -19%.
A strong group spends 5 minutes clarifying Tejomay's needs, 10 computing, 10 agreeing and 5 presenting, and reaches Rs 8 crore in arbitrage, Rs 12.8 crore in short-duration debt and Rs 19.2 crore of equity split Rs 10, 6.8 and 2.4 crore across Funds A, B and C.
Step 2What do the first fifteen minutes produce?

The needs, turned into rupees. Rs 8 crore is needed within two years, so it goes to Fund E, arbitrage, which barely moves. Two years of spending, Rs 2.4 crore, goes to Fund D. That leaves Rs 29.6 crore of long-term money, and the only real debate is how much of it can be equity without breaking the 20% loss limit. Use the pack's worst falls as the test. If equity is split Rs 10, 6.8 and 2.4 crore across A, B and C, a repeat of each fund's worst fall costs Rs 5.62 crore, -19.0% of Rs 29.6 crore. That is about 65% equity in the long-term money, and the remaining Rs 10.4 crore joins the spending reserve in Fund D.

FundRoleRs croreWorst fallCost
A, large-cap indexCore equity, cheapest10.025%0.20%
B, flexi-cap activeSecond equity manager6.830%1.00%
C, small-cap activeSmall satellite2.445%0.90%
D, short-duration debtSpending reserve and ballast12.81%0.40%
E, arbitrageVenture money, due within 2 years8.00%0.35%
Portfolio40.00.47%
The agreed portfolio holds Rs 19.2 crore of equity across Funds A, B and C, Rs 12.8 crore in short-duration debt and Rs 8 crore in arbitrage, at a blended cost of 0.47% a year.
Step 3Where do groups go wrong in the agreeing block?

On Fund C. Its 21% five-year return is the brightest number in the pack, and someone always argues for a large slice. A past return is a description of one period, not a plan; Fund C also has the pack's worst fall, 45%, which alone would eat most of the loss budget if it were a large holding. Keeping it to Rs 2.4 crore, 6% of the total, lets the group acknowledge the argument without breaking the client's limit. A good way to settle the disagreement is to test each proposal against the 20% limit out loud, so the data decides rather than the loudest voice.

Close the presentation with one voice and one page: the needs, the portfolio, the loss test and the costs. The blended cost of 0.47% is worth saying, because leaning on Fund A as the core keeps it low. Say the limit too: five-year figures describe a single stretch of markets, and the worst-fall test is a stress test, not a ceiling on what can happen.

Where candidates lose it

Groups lose marks by opening the fund table first and debating returns for twenty minutes, then rushing a portfolio in the last two. The client's dated needs settle most of the answer, and assessors notice who brings the group back to them.

Individuals lose marks by trying to win the discussion. Interrupting, ignoring a quiet member's good point or presenting a personal answer instead of the group's reads as poor judgement, however sharp the numbers.

What the interviewer asks next

  • Halfway through, the assessor says the venture will need Rs 12 crore. What changes, and how does the group absorb it quickly?
  • One group member insists on 25% in Fund C. How do you handle it in the room?
  • Why hold both an index fund and an active flexi-cap fund rather than one of them?

Asked at UBS, Wealth Management, São Paulo, 2026 (Wall Street Oasis): Candidates were given a complex business scenario involving portfolio management

← Case 014Calculate the all-in annual cost for an Rs 8 crore client paying a 0.75% advisory fee, fund expenses of 1.1% on Rs 5 crore, a PMS fee of 2% on Rs 2 crore and 0.1% in transaction costs on the whole.Case 016 →A 60-year-old with Rs 5 crore spends Rs 20 lakh a year, rising with 6% inflation. Build a three-bucket plan, size each bucket, set the refill rule, and show it surviving a bad start.

Company names and figures are illustrative.

Fin Maverick

Finance education that ends in a job, not a certificate that gathers dust. Built for young India.

LEARN
CalculatorsFrameworksComparisonsInterview RoadmapsShowdown
RESOURCES
All CoursesFree CoursesBootcampsNISMQuarksAI for Finance
COMPANY
AboutJob openingPartnership
LEGAL
Privacy PolicyTerms & ConditionsContent LicenseReturn & Refund Policy
© 2026 FIN MAVERICK / BUILT FOR INDIA.DO FINANCE, DO NOT JUST READ ABOUT IT.